Mystery Box

Last Call Items • No returns admitted

*Mystery Box is Final Sale*

Discover luxury in every step with the Paul Evans Mystery Box. Handcrafted to perfection, each mystery shoe is a testament to unparalleled craftsmanship and sophistication. Simply choose your size, add to cart, and unveil a premium pair at a fraction of the cost.

👞 Handcrafted Excellence: Elevate your style with meticulously handcrafted shoes that exude luxury. The Paul Evans Mystery Box brings you the epitome of craftsmanship and refinement.

🎁 Surprise Unleashed: Unbox an element of excitement! Select your size, add to cart, and let us surprise you with a carefully curated mystery shoe, showcasing versatile styles and timeless elegance.

💼 Variety in Every Box: From classic oxfords to modern loafers, each Mystery Box offers a unique blend of styles and colors. Embrace the surprise, knowing that your mystery shoe complements your distinct taste.

🌟 Quality Assured: With Paul Evans, quality is non-negotiable. Rest easy knowing your mystery shoe meets the same impeccable standards that define our brand – premium materials and expert craftsmanship.

🔒 Limited Quantities: Don't miss out on this exclusive opportunity to experience Paul Evans luxury at an unbeatable price. Secure your Mystery Box now and redefine your footwear collection.

Unbox elegance, embrace the mystery – Paul Evans Mystery Box, your gateway to luxury!

  • Paul Evans size runs full size large. Order full size down in Paul Evans from US dress shoe size. For example, if you wear size US 10 dress shoe, order PE 9
  • Alternatively, order one and a half sizes below your Brannock device measurement. If you measure a 10 on the Brannock, order PE 8.5
  • Blake construction
  • Handmade in Italy


    Italy has long been the center of world fashion. Sophisticated craftsmanship, an eye for timeless designs, and high-quality materials make Italy the greatest shoe producing country in the world.


    Mystery Box

    average rating 5.0 out of 5
    Based on 1 review
    • 5 Stars
      1 Review
    • 4 Stars
      0 Reviews
    • 3 Stars
      0 Reviews
    • 2 Stars
      0 Reviews
    • 1 Star
      0 Reviews
    100% of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend
    Rated 5 out of 5
    Rated 5 out of 5
    Rated 0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2, where minus 2 is Runs Small, 0 is True to Size and 2 is Runs Large
    Review posted
    Reviewed by Daniel S., from United States
    Verified Buyer
    Age Range
    45 - 54
    My Experience
    Exceeded Expectations
    Bought For
    • Work
    • Everyday
    Products Standout
    • Comfortable
    • High Quality
    • Attracts Compliments
    • Unique
    Rated 5 out of 5

    Nice Surprise

    I rarely ever do anything that is really spontaneous and unexpected. I probably would not have bought these myself but I really like them and they look much better on me than I thought they would. I got the Oxblood single monk straps. They ran out of my size but I might have done it again.

    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5
    Rated 5 out of 5
    Rated 0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2, where minus 2 is Runs Small, 0 is True to Size and 2 is Runs Large
    Was this helpful?